by Peke » Sun Aug 27, 2017 11:07 am
Hi,
I've been able to analyze here are results:
- "2 Untitled1 saved by GW 6.30 - title OK in Mp3tag, Explorer and MM.wav" -> Contains only Standard "LISTINFO" chunk and thus all Chunks are under RIFF ISO standard file is OK
- "3 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83 - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, missing in MM.wav" -> "ID3 " Chunk defined to be length 41 Bytes but actually it is 42, uses ID3v2.3 tag format
- "4 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, missing in MM.wav" -> Identical to "3 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83 - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, missing in MM.wav" so it observes same issue
- "5 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i changed config - title OK in Mp3tag, Explorer and MM - now bad in MM!.wav" -> same as above only change it uses UNICODE ID3v2.4 tag format
- "6 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i UTF8 - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, bad in MM.wav" -> same as above only change it uses UTF8 ID3v2.4 tag format
- "7 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i ISO - title OK in Mp3tag, Explorer and MM.wav" -> "ID3 " present but formatted according to RIFF/WAV ISO Format CHUNK and have correct length it shows/import OK eg. it is correctly terminated without extra ZERO Byte on file end unlike previous 4
NOTE: "ID3 " Chunk is not standard chunk by RIFF ISO see
http://www.robotplanet.dk/audio/wav_meta_data/ ,
https://github.com/mpruett/audiofile/issues/3 ,
http://wavmetadata.blogspot.rs/ (one with most correct info)
Unfortunately there is a BUG in both MP3TAG and in MMW PLUGIN which makes this bit complicated to debug.
For MMW I'll Add bug in order to Support ID3v2.3 "ID3 " Chunk eg. files 3 and 4 and add correction to Ignore junk ZERO Byte on file end and as you already opened issue on MP3tag you can rise bug there. For that Purpose I uploaded manually corrected files 5 and 6 onto
http://www.happymonkeying.com/XoXoTemp/ ... _issue.zip so that you can include them in your archive on Dropbox for future use.
Here is a PIC of my manual FIX (NOTE: FILE size in RIFF Header also needs to be corrected as highlighted)
Hi,
I've been able to analyze here are results:
[list=1]
[*]"2 Untitled1 saved by GW 6.30 - title OK in Mp3tag, Explorer and MM.wav" -> Contains only Standard "LISTINFO" chunk and thus all Chunks are under RIFF ISO standard file is OK
[*]"3 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83 - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, missing in MM.wav" -> "ID3 " Chunk defined to be length 41 Bytes but actually it is 42, uses ID3v2.3 tag format
[*]"4 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, missing in MM.wav" -> Identical to "3 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83 - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, missing in MM.wav" so it observes same issue
[*]"5 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i changed config - title OK in Mp3tag, Explorer and MM - now bad in MM!.wav" -> same as above only change it uses UNICODE ID3v2.4 tag format
[*]"6 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i UTF8 - title OK in Mp3tag and Explorer, bad in MM.wav" -> same as above only change it uses UTF8 ID3v2.4 tag format
[*]"7 Untitled1 saved by Mp3tag v2.83i ISO - title OK in Mp3tag, Explorer and MM.wav" -> "ID3 " present but formatted according to RIFF/WAV ISO Format CHUNK and have correct length it shows/import OK eg. it is correctly terminated without extra ZERO Byte on file end unlike previous 4[/list]
NOTE: "ID3 " Chunk is not standard chunk by RIFF ISO see http://www.robotplanet.dk/audio/wav_meta_data/ , https://github.com/mpruett/audiofile/issues/3 , http://wavmetadata.blogspot.rs/ (one with most correct info)
Unfortunately there is a BUG in both MP3TAG and in MMW PLUGIN which makes this bit complicated to debug.
For MMW I'll Add bug in order to Support ID3v2.3 "ID3 " Chunk eg. files 3 and 4 and add correction to Ignore junk ZERO Byte on file end and as you already opened issue on MP3tag you can rise bug there. For that Purpose I uploaded manually corrected files 5 and 6 onto http://www.happymonkeying.com/XoXoTemp/Corrected_Tracks_for_MM_WAV_tag_issue.zip so that you can include them in your archive on Dropbox for future use.
Here is a PIC of my manual FIX (NOTE: FILE size in RIFF Header also needs to be corrected as highlighted)
[img]http://www.happymonkeying.com/XoXoTemp/Corrected_Tracks_for_MM_WAV_tag_issue.jpg[/img]